← Back to articles On Campus

How Why Nations Fail changed my perspective

Issue 41 p. 39
Gia Linh
How Why Nations Fail changed my perspective

"The important thing is not to stop questioning. Curiosity has its own reason for existing." — Albert Einstein

"It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it." — Aristotle

Stop what you're doing right now. I haven't even finished one-third of this book, yet it has completely shaken my entire worldview! The book is Why Nations Fail by Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson, and it starts with a puzzle so brilliantly simple that I sometimes feel foolish for not having thought of it myself.

It begins with a fascinating case study: the city of Nogales

The same people, same geography, same climate, same culture, yet split by the US-Mexico border. So why is the Arizona side (US), with an average income of $30,000, safe, prosperous, and healthy, while the Sonora side (Mexico), just a few steps away, is plagued by poverty, crime, and a poor public health system?

What happened?

I bet if Earth's population is over 8 billion, about two-thirds of them — including my past self — would believe the reasons stem from natural and socio-cultural factors ("people in tropical countries are lazy," the "Protestant work ethic theory," etc.) or simply think it's because leaders lack the qualities to make sound decisions. That was me before reading this book. After reading it? Boom! The truth is revealed!

The final boss behind everything

Just like a game needs rules to function, a society needs institutions to be established and operated. And those who live under these institutions are the players — depending on the institutions, they become either heroes or villains. Some systems lift people up, letting anyone dream, build, and rise through effort. Others quietly chain them down, turning talent into frustration and ambition into despair.

It's wild to realize that the difference between prosperity and poverty isn't luck, geography, or even culture — it's the rules we live by. And once you see that, you can't unsee it.

How did we get here?

I've only reached Chapter 4, but I am already stunned by another mind-blowing truth: if choosing the right institution can determine whether you become a good or bad person, why don't countries simply choose the right one? In the end, the truth is that institutions evolve over centuries, through chaos, pandemics, revolutions — tiny differences that send countries on opposite paths.

"We don't see things as they are, we see them as we are." — Anaïs Nin

If you've ever looked at a world map and wondered "why…?" then seriously, add this masterpiece to your cart immediately. 10/10, no notes!